I always had a weird feeling about the birth control pill. Though I didn’t know much about it, it seemed controversial. I also didn’t like the idea of taking anything that would mess with my hormones. But when I got married, I was a junior in college and was planning on six more years of school. Needless to say, we weren’t exactly ready to have kids yet. I knew I didn’t want an IUD or an implant, so it seemed like the pill was the only option. Though it did cross my mind that since I wasn’t cycling anyway, I probably didn’t need it… But there was still the chance I could spontaneously ovulate and I didn’t want to take that chance. Unfortunately, back then I was completely unaware of fertility awareness methods, such as the Creighton Model System (CrMS).
Starting on the Pill
I was hesitant about starting the pill. I had a laundry list of questions about how it worked and possible side effects, but ultimately, I went through with it. Because of my amenorrhea, my doctor said I might possibly have PCOS. However, she also said it didn’t matter if I tested to find out. She would treat it with birth control either way. HUGE red flag! If a doctor told me that now, my first instinct would be, RUN! Even back then, I wasn’t satisfied with the answer. We knew we wanted children eventually and it would be better to know upfront if there might be complications. But I felt silly asking to do all the testing, so I let it go.
The Pill Does Not Regulate the Cycle
As many women are, I was falsely told that the pill would ‘regulate’ my cycles. Although it may seem like that, it is not the case. Instead, it shuts down the menstrual cycle. The ‘period’ you get while on the pill is simply a withdrawal bleed when you stop taking it for a week each month. It’s not the result of ovulation or a natural drop in progesterone. With the reproductive system turned off, some menstrual symptoms may improve temporarily, but they will return when you stop taking it. It is a band-aid approach that doesn’t solve the root cause of any issues. Not to mention there are many risks and side effects and some versions of the pill can be abortifacients.
The pill works by preventing ovulation, but it also thins the uterine lining. That way, if ovulation did occur and an egg was fertilized, the embryo wouldn’t be able to implant. This is what makes it a possible abortifacient. To learn more about the issues with hormonal contraception, I recommend watching The Business of Birth Control or reading Lisa Hendrickson-Jack’s book The Fifth Vital Sign. She also has a podcast: “Fertility Friday”.
Finding Alternatives
I had only been on the pill for a few months when I saw an ad for the Natural Cycles app. I didn’t like the idea of being on birth control, but also didn’t have any side effects yet. The app was intriguing, but it was quite a while before I made the leap to get off the pill. Natural Cycles works by tracking basal body temperature (BBT) first thing each morning. BBT rises significantly after ovulation and remains elevated throughout the luteal phase. This app is a form of the rhythm method (not a true fertility awareness method) because it uses your temperature data from past cycles to predict when ovulation will occur. Because a woman is only fertile for the six days prior to ovulation, it calculates when she would be fertile or not.
The problem is that BBT cannot actually predict ovulation–it only tells you when ovulation has passed by a sustained rise in temperature. In order to successfully achieve or avoid pregnancy, you need to know when ovulation is on the way. This rhythm method can work if you have a very regular cycle and ovulate consistently on the same day each month, but most women have some variation in when they ovulate, so using past cycles’ temperature data is not very accurate.
Getting Off the Pill
Fast forward a little over a year to spring of 2021. I planned pursue an online master’s instead of veterinary school, so we found ourselves moving to the country. We’d also decided that since the rest of my schooling would be quite flexible, we could start trying for a baby sooner. Although we were still planning to wait a year or so, I got off the pill in May of that year to start trying to resolve the menstrual issues I had been masking for the past year and a half. I did try using the Natural Cycles app at first, but it didn’t tell me much since I didn’t ovulate at all during that time.
Feeling Like Myself Again
Later that summer, an interesting realization hit me—I felt like myself again! Since spring of 2020, I had been dealing with some pretty rough anxiety. I had a few panic attacks and a lot of gut issues that caused me to lose a lot of weight. I was quite unwell and came pretty close to seeking out a therapist. But then one day, I realized I wasn’t in that state of fight or flight anymore! And I’ve been so much better ever since! I can’t prove causation, but it definitely correlated with my time on birth control.
That fall, I switched to a more integrative health clinic. I had an ultrasound and did a lot of testing. I started some supplements and hormone replacements too. When none of that worked, my doctor referred me to reproductive endocrinology. I was crushed. First, it was three months before they could see me. Second, I knew that they would just offer Clomid or Letrozole and if those didn’t work, would refer me to IVF. And IVF is not an option for us—mainly for ethical reasons (that’s a whole blog post on its own), but the cost is certainly prohibitive too.
Restorative Reproductive Healthcare
I listened to a bunch of podcasts during this time—mainly “Food, Freedom, Fertility” and “Fertility Friday“, that I mentioned earlier. A couple of these episodes mentioned NaPro Technology. Although I didn’t fully understand what it was or how it worked, I was willing to explore it more. I had looked into it a while back, but the only NaPro doctor in my area was a man and I was very insistent about only seeing female doctors about these issues. However, this looked to be the most promising option and I’m so glad I went with it! I called the clinic and had an appointment the following week!
In order to start using NaPro technology, I had to learn to chart my cycles using CrMS. I began working with a FertilityCare Practitioner who taught me the method and I was able to understand my cycles so much better (once I started cycling again, that is). It was through my chart data that I was given a formal PCOS diagnosis and was able to have surgery to help correct it. Had I stuck with the conventional route, I never would have gotten these answers or treatment! I’m so grateful to have found this system of restorative reproductive healthcare! So much so, that I am now planning to be trained as a FertilityCare Practitioner so that I can help other women and couples understand their fertility.
Stay tuned for next week’s post where I will cover some of the nutritional aspects of fertility!




